Day 92: Friday
Good morning Zak,
Zak, you’re too clever for me. I think I must have spent twenty minutes mulling over your use of the letter ‘d’ before I got the pun.
Anyway, you raise a good question: is technology partially responsible for the Excess I’ve been whining about?
When I first got music notation software, I went through a phase of writing all my music directly into the computer. Eventually I stopped that and went back to writing by hand before copying into a notation program. The quality of my music improved drastically at that point.
I know correlation is not the same thing as causation. But I do think there’s something to this…
A lot of music and art in general is predicated on the mechanism of pattern recognition.
“In effect aesthetic pleasure derives from the fact that the soul recognizes in the material the harmony of its own structure.”
—Umberto Eco (In reference to the views of Ugo di San Vittore)
I don’t know if the physical process of writing by hand makes it easier for me to recognize patterns. At the very least, it makes the artistic processes much more intimate.
But patterns are a big deal. The more arcane a pattern is, the more rewarding it is when our brain/soul recognizes it. But if it’s too arcane, of course, there’s the danger that we won’t recognize it at all.
I’ve written before about the pattern of pairing love with death in medieval poetry:
“All I can say is that the collective wisdom of Western poets throughout history tells us that love is a kind of death.”
That’s maybe one of the most interesting patterns in Western literature. It’s something that resonates with us all on a fundamental level.
That’s why people like the story of Paolo and Francesca so much. Frankly I get a little annoyed by the excessive popularity of Inferno Canto V. The fame of Francesca’s little vignette has tragically eclipsed the rest of the Divine Comedy in popular culture. I went to Bergamo and saw this excessively Romantic depiction.
While the hipster in me is, as I said, a bit annoyed, I do understand why people like this kind of thing. This story should be popular. When we experience a piece like this, our soul recognizes in the material the harmony of its own structure. We understand on a fundamental human level that life couldn’t really be a thing without love to the point of death.
That’s easy to recognize. As far as other patterns go… a hyphen may be well advised.